2004: Middlebury – Chip Kenyon Arena
Championship: Norwich 2, Middlebury 1
(Shootout decided game)

2005: Potsdam – Maxcy Hall
Championship: Middlebury 3, Plattsburgh 2

2006: Norwich - Kreitzberg Arena
Championship Norwich 4, Plattsburgh 2

2007: Plattsburgh - Stafford Arena
Championship Plattsburgh 5, Norwich 3